How Germany Became Russia's Chief Enabler

United States President Ronald Reagan, United Kingdom Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, Pope John Paul II, and Soviet Union President Mikhail Gorbachev are typically the four people who most praise for ending the Cold War. After them, many would say German Chancellor Helmut Kohl deserves credit. His navigation in reunifying Germany played a pivotal role in freeing millions of Europeans from communism. When Reagan delivered his “tear down this wall” line, Kohl was sitting on stage right behind him. Given Germany’s history in the Cold War, most would think that the nation would follow the lead of many Eastern European nations and counter Russia. Unfortunately, since the Cold War, Germany has repeatedly coddled and emboldened Russia.

Kohl’s successor, Gerhard Schröder, proved even more destructive. Schröder was chancellor when Yeltsin controversially “appointed” Putin “acting president.” Despite these warning signs, Schröder pursued the illogical goal of ending nuclear power in Germany, and then offsetted this energy loss with a “$5.7 billion pipeline” from Russia. In 2004, Putin started trying to influence Ukraine’s elections. Schröder undermined the European Union’s criticism of Putin’s actions by claiming the elections had no flaws and that Putin believed in democracy.

Right after Schröder left office in 2005, his “illogical” decisions on energy started to make sense…for him. Schröder took a position with the gas company, Gazprom, from the deal that he set up with Russia. The position reportedly paid him as much as $1 million a year. Close to 20 years later, Schröder remains close with Putin and Gazprom. Schröder refuses to apologize for his relationships, and recently had a friendly visit with Putin, amidst Russia’s atrocities.

Angela Merkel drove Schröder from power. Merkel grew up in Eastern Germany, so many hoped she would understand the importance of freedom. Merkel initially showed promise with Russia when she condemned Putin’s annexation of Crimea and threatened sanctions. Kohl and Schröder criticized her for this response. Despite this acknowledgement of Putin as a threat, Merkel pursued a second energy deal for Germany with Russia. The United States and many experts objected to this deal, but Merkel ignored them. In 2018, Heiko Maas, a key diplomat under Merkel, laughed at then-US President Trump when Trump said in a speech at the UN, that Germany could end up reliant on Russia for energy. Today, Maas has not commented on the matter, and Merkel will not admit she was wrong.

Merkel’s successor, Olaf Scholz, has been in office for less than a year. Many have criticized Scholz for doing the bare minimum on Russia and even blocking proactive measures, while leaders from other countries, like Finland and Estonia, take the lead. Scholz’s administrations recently faced embarrassment when they had to fire the head of their cybersecurity, Arne Schönbohm, amid media reports of Schönbohm’s ties to Russian intelligence. Schönbohm received the position during Merkel’s administration.

All post-Cold War German chancellors have a stain on their record for enabling Russia. But why? All the chancellors had their own agendas, but all have purported to do their actions for national interest. Now all of Europe is in a terrible situation, including Germany. Additionally, the German public has seemingly asked for this. In 2014, polls showed Germans did not want Merkel to do more on Russia after Putin’s actions in Ukraine. Recent polls show Germans do support action against Russia, but there is some question of how long that will last.

Germans are never afraid to harshly rebuke the United States and its policies. But given their own failures, the government and its people need to do more self-reflection. Until then, the world should look elsewhere for leadership in Europe.

Todd Carney is an international lawyer and a frequent writer on international issues. He earned his juris doctorate from Harvard Law School.