Australia Is Right: Manning Is Not a Whistleblower

In August 2013, when military judge Colonel Denise Lind sentenced Private First Class Bradley (now Chelsea) Manning to 35 years in jail, she never described Manning as a whistleblower. In fact, she said Manning’s conduct:

So, let’s get a few facts inserted in the Chelsea Manning debate about whether or not to allow her a visa to enter Australia. Despite the media breathlessly describing Manning as a whistleblower, she is far from that. In fact, if she thought she was a whistleblower she could have availed herself of the 1988 Military Whistleblowers Protection Act.

Under Section 501 of Australia’s Migration Act, the Minister can refuse a person a visa on character grounds if they have been sentenced to prison for one year or longer; in Manning’s case it was 35 years. And remember that as president, Barack Obama simply commuted Manning’s sentence; the punishment remains on her record.

Manning was not some battle-scarred veteran sickened by the violence they had seen through too many operational tours. She was a volunteer who joined the army, was assigned to be an intelligence analyst and, as the prosecution established, underwent all the appropriate training regarding information security for classified material. In fact it was a base skill for her employment.

Manning is not, and has never been, a whistleblower.

The Australian Government is well within its rights to question whether someone convicted of espionage, dishonourably discharged from the US military and whose reckless actions while deployed on operations were described by a judge as dangerous to others should enter the country, let alone be paid for her appearance. Manning is not, and never has been, a whistleblower. She is someone convicted of espionage who was given a long prison sentence.

Dr. Rodger Shanahan is a Research Fellow at the Lowy Institute. A former army officer, he had extensive service within the Parachute Battalion Group (PBG) and has had operational service with the UN in South Lebanon and Syria, with the PBG in East Timor, in Beirut during the 2006 war, and in Afghanistan. He was the former director of the Army's Land Warfare Studies Centre, and has also been posted to the Australian Embassies in Riyadh and Abu Dhabi. Dr. Shanahan has MAs in International Relations and Middle East Studies from the ANU, and a Ph.D. in Arab and Islamic Studies from the University of Sydney.

This article appeared originally at Lowy Institute's the interpreter.