Loose Blimps and Loose Logic
Anchoring the Future Arguments of Defense Reform
Published Feb. 9, 2016 • Read time: 5m
Recently, Secretary of Defense Ash Carter has previewed Fiscal Year 2017’s $582.7 billion defense budget, noting “In this budget we’re taking the long view. We have to. Even as we fight today’s fights, we must also be prepared for fights that might come 10, 20 or 30 years down the road.” The Secretary is right, today we’re facing the persistence of the ISIS threat, the Syrian refugee crisis, rouge nations perfecting nuclear weapons and terrorism events across the globe.
This week, the White House is set to release the President’s budget request in full and as Washington is a buzz with budget it’s critical we remember that our nation’s defense budget is more than dollars and cents—it’s about security, projecting strength, protecting U.S. citizens and our warfighters, and preparing for critical current and future threats.
One of those critical threats is cruise missiles, particularly here in the National Capital Region.
Last fall, on October 28, when a JLENS (Joint Land Attack Cruise Missile Defense Elevated Netted Sensor System) aerostat was being tested as part of our nation’s cruise missile defense strategy at Aberdeen Proving Ground broke tether, and drifted across the Maryland and Pennsylvania countryside, the media was quick to criticize and politicize this “blimp.”
Even before the blimp gained an uncontrolled altitude of 15,000 feet, the event earned the Twitter moniker #Blimpontheloose. The commentary ranged from late night comedy to Defense News intoning “After Blimp Broke Free and Crashed, JLENS Program Hangs by a Thread.”
JLENS attracted more than 15 minutes of fame on the 24-hour news cycle of October 28. The surface sensationalism can fit into a 140-character tweet: “20 year developmental effort; over $2.8 billion dollars; down-scoped from 16 systems to 2; not yet operational; can’t even tie it down!”
But below the ‘gotcha’ media clamor the JLENS episode illustrates important choices germane to our emerging national defense debate:
Current versus Potential Threats. JLENS fills a gap in our ability to track moving low altitude and surface targets at range. In light of the recent horrors in Paris and San Bernardino, tracking hostile cruise missiles in-bound on our East Coast may seem a low priority -- until the hour missiles launch from off-shore submarines, warships, or even a commercial container ship. Our defense decisions must balance the urgency of present threats against the potential impact of future ones.
Service-Domain Priorities. JLENS is a ground-based system that operates at 10,000 feet. Each service has capabilities that extend far beyond its “home domain;” such capabilities pose ever greater potential for joint synergy. In this case the Army, under immense budget pressures, confronts a decision to pursue this new mission or abandon it – along with the recent unfavorable press – in favor of more traditional and urgent land requirements. Such hard decisions will be a feature of our future strategic choices. DoD and the Joint Staff will be increasingly involved in such cross-domain decisions, and should be prepared to fund them as joint requirements.
Budget Math. Too often the budget math stops with a tally of platform development and procurement costs. But strategic comparisons must extend to sustainment costs. From this perspective JLENS is 500-700 percent less expensive than its aircraft-based alternatives (JSTARS and EWACS), and requires 50 percent of the manpower. But only if completed: $2.7B of the developmental cost is already expended; the 2016 budget for the first year of its operational exercise is only $40.6M. $2.7B is a lot of money on anybody’s calculator: compared to doing nothing, it is expensive. Compared to less-capable legacy platforms, it is efficient. Compared to rebuilding a major East Coast city, it’s a bargain.
Operational Integration. Platforms are as valuable – or vulnerable -- as the operational concepts they enable. Once launched, JLENS provides continuous surveillance capability aloft for 30 days. Its advanced radar systems can see from Boston to Norfolk, affording decision and reaction times that far exceed the seconds of JSTARS/EWACS warning time. NORAD integrates its data with the FAA and the JLENS fire control information feeds a wide range of defensive weapon systems such as Patriot and the Advanced Medium Range Air-to-Air Missile, or AMRAAM. Like any stationary asset, JLENS looks vulnerable against a peer armed with precision weapons, but its vulnerability drops if nested into an integrated air defense.
Strategic Flexibility. The JLENS aerostat can hang alternative sensors and radars as technologies – and threats -- evolve. Modular combinations of platforms and payloads enable adaptation in a future of dynamic uncertainty and complexity. Flexibility in application is also at a premium. One can also imagine JLENS employment to reassure Gulf States apprehensive of Iranian missiles, to monitor a tentative Ukraine ceasefire agreement, or along the Korean DMZ."
JLENS competes with a vast series of alternative trades confronting our joint and service leaders. Speaking at the CSIS Full Spectrum Missile Defense forum on 4 December, BG (ret) Ken Todorov (former Deputy Commander of the Missile Defense Agency) noted, “The cruise missile challenge from our more near-peer competitors is very real … let’s not focus on the platform, let’s focus on the capabilities brought by the platform – let’s restart the test.”
A continuation of the JLENS operational exercise at Aberdeen Proving Grounds is critical and will afford our leaders a better understanding of its effectiveness. The Nation confronts tough strategic choices. Let’s anchor those choices in logic more substantive than a 140-character tweet.
David Fastabend is a former defense executive and retired Army officer who was Director of Strategy, Plans and Policy on the Army Staff. A civil engineer, Fastabend began his military career with the Army Corps of Engineers.
Brigadier General (retired) John McGuiness is a former Army Program Executive Officer with over 20 years of experience managing Department of Defense Acquisition programs. McGuiness was Deputy Commander of US Army Research, Development and Engineering Command at Aberdeen Proving Grounds.

End the Jones Act Waiver
By Mark H. Buzby • RealClearDefense
Prediction Markets Are Becoming a New Frontline for Military Operational Security
By Yang Yunke • RealClearDefense
Can Robots Bring Maneuver Warfare Back?
By Ayeza Areej • RealClearDefense
Buy Smarter, Fly More
By Jeff Kojac • RealClearDefense
Stop Gutting the Conventional Army
By R.D. Hooker, Jr. • RealClearDefense

Hung Cao Facing Contentious Confirmation To Become Navy Secretary
By Konstantin Toropin • Associated Press
U.S. Marines Expand M27 Rifle Contract
By Inder Singh Bisht
Kadena AFB Gets First F-15EX Eagle IIs
By Emily Ryan Miller, Defence Blog
Hung Cao Facing Contentious Confirmation To Become Navy Secretary
By AP
Fair Winds, Peacoat and Desert Camo: Navy Makes Big Changes to Seabag
By MTimes
