
Facing the Inevitable: Preparing for the Next War Requires Changing Paradigms
Published Feb. 23, 2022 • Read time: 11m
Last week’s remarks by Speaker Pelosi, encouraging American athletes to avoid "angering" the "ruthless" Chinese government, and subsequent lackluster ratings for the Beijing Olympics, suggest an increasing public awareness of the problematic nature of the rise of the People's Republic of China (PRC). Whether there will be a realization of what the ascendance of such a brutal and powerful adversary requires of the American public and leaders remains to be seen.
Expressly making the point last June, Cai Xia, the dissident former professor of Ideology at the Chinese Communist Party’s Central Party School, released a paper giving her insider's perspective on the failure of engagement by the United States with the PRC. She argues the PRC and the United States have been and will continue to be strategic adversaries. She calls for an acceptance by U.S. leadership that engagement has failed and the adoption of "hard-headed defensive measures" and "offensive pressure" to stress a "fragile" Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
Professor Cai is one among several voices asserting the world's two preeminent powers are on a collision course. Whether the analytical framework predicting this inevitable fight is geographic, diplomatic, or economic, the United States is faced with its own geo-strategic version of Pascal's wager. Given revelations of recent PRC weapons development, preparing for the next war would seem to be the winning bet.
Preparing for such a conflict against a peer competitor is no simple task. The CCP is a formidable adversary with an active and integrated government approach to fighting and defeating the United States. To counter this, the United States must mobilize itself more broadly than has been seen in 80 years. It will need to undergo intellectual and emotional phase shifts and adopt changes to six key paradigms. This will enable the United States to compete and win against a daunting and coordinated opponent, intent on reshaping the world to its benefit at the expense of the freedom and prosperity of others.
Washington Built the Hub-and-Spokes – Australia and Japan Are Rewiring It
By Prodding Taiwan, Russia Takes Its Alignment With China to New Heights
Watch What Trump Does in Asia, Not What He Says
How the Quad Can Work With Southeast Asia
Presently, the U.S. government (USG) and its people have only partially embraced the perspectives necessary to drive social, economic, political, or military preparations for this potential war. To harness the strengths of U.S. society, enhance deterrence, and properly posture for a potential fight, the USG and the American citizenry must adopt the following new paradigms.
Paradigm Shift 1: The CCP is an existential threat, not simply an economic competitor
The essential paradigm shift for America is to accept that the CCP is an existential threat to the United States and its present way of life. The world economic system, the broad acceptance of the rule of law, liberal democracy (its inherent value of the individual), all of these are under deliberate attack from the current rulers of the PRC. Left unchecked, they will use their power to enact political warfare and to institute oppressive governance wherever they identify the CCP has interests, incrementally rewriting the standards for global affairs just as it did for domestic matters in Hong Kong and its genocidal policies toward the Uyghurs. The future of American freedom and prosperity will depend on the ability to confront and contain the PRC in matters both foreign and domestic.
This demands a concerted plan to prepare the population for war, a campaign to inform and educate U.S. citizens about the threat posed by the CCP and the malign acts the neo-totalitarian regime is perpetrating against its own people and across the globe. Particularly, emphasizing those acts directed specifically at the United States. It will be imperative to link the aggressive behaviors of the CCP to a need for American action, justifying those costs (and reduced economic interaction) as the price of freedom.
Paradigm Shift 2: Emphasis on the obligations, not the entitlements of citizenship
More critical than information campaigns clearly identifying Chinese misdeeds and public service announcements contrasting CCP despotism with the benefits of the liberal order will be building public awareness of civic responsibilities through a revamped and widespread push for effective civics education. The effort must highlight the soundness of the American experiment, the exceptionalism of that system, and the responsibility of the citizen to participate in and defend the American democracy.
This "attitude adjustment" is a vital part of U.S. preparation. The final report of the National Commission on Military, National and Public Service, Inspired to Serve, provides a roadmap for beginning this conditioning. Its recommendations encompass methods that provide diverse opportunities to contribute meaningfully to national service, educate and encourage patriotism and bolster the dedication required across governments (federal/state/local) and throughout industry.
Ultimately, the contest with the CCP requires a whole of nation solution with greater sacrifice and service than U.S. citizenry are currently accustomed to. The All-Volunteer Force, for example, will not be enough to meet the needs of the services. The United States should begin now to modernize and update the draft, commencing routine rehearsals to exercise the Selective Service System. These rehearsals should include processing representative portions of the draftee pool all the way through the Medical Entrance Processing Stations. Similarly, The United States should begin mobilizing key industries to demonstrate and improve important industrial capacities. Such practice will prepare the nation, the economy, the services, and the draft system for the future. Importantly, these steps provide deterrent effects, articulating the severity of the threat to the U.S. population and signaling the adversary the United States is serious about protecting the nation and its interests.
Paradigm Shift 3: Strategic competition requires a competitive resourcing strategy
In 1960, the U.S. defense budget accounted for 9% of GDP. In 2021 it was 3.3%. The Chinese are outproducing the United States in their efforts to modernize the People's Liberation Army and U.S. leaders have expressed concern that this trajectory is leading to an impending loss of military advantage for the United States. It is unreasonable to expect the U.S. defense industry and the Department of Defense (DOD) to effectively provide for the nation's security if the resources provided are not in accordance with the challenge. Since the last Cold War ended, there has been a tremendous peace dividend, but after 30 years, the strategic environment has changed, and so too must U.S. resourcing strategy. Tax, fiscal and monetary policies must all change to support a rebalancing of spending; sacred cows of entitlements, tax rates, and federal debt burdens will all require reconsideration.
When America invests its treasure in this manner, it carries with it an obligation to improve DOD stewardship. It will not be sufficient to triple the expenditure and do more of the same. Instead, the future force should come through more agile procurement. Systems will need to be modular, less exquisite, more numerous, more affordable, and more attritable. If the United States begins this process promptly, it will also reinvigorate key sectors in the nation's industrial base and those of allies.
Paradigm Shift 4: Space is a global commons that demands defense
As the United States invests its resources to prepare, it must move past the question of whether to militarize space and onto the question of how to use military force to keep space free and accessible to all. Space and the high seas have much in common. Our telecommunications and the "network of things" are already deeply dependent upon space. As commercial applications from resource extraction to travel become more prevalent in space, the already significant impact of actions beyond the atmosphere on the lives and lifestyles of Americans will only increase. No longer a place for occasional and inspirational scientific adventures in research, rather the modern equivalent of Mahan's venue for Sea Power, the critical need for a military presence to regulate and secure U.S. interests across the space domain will only grow.
Americans should expect that the nascent space force will increasingly resemble the other services, with growing requirements for forces and platforms that the service leverages to protect against the malign intent of the PRC, which has already demonstrated the ability to take offensive actions in space and is moving aggressively to expand its position within the domain. As General Dickinson, the Commander of U.S. Space Command, recently noted, successful deterrence and strategic victory in future conflicts will depend upon a robust U.S. warfighting capability in space.
Paradigm Shift 5: Nuclear non-proliferation is not an absolute good
U.S. security guarantees and advocacy against the proliferation of nuclear weapons have been tightly linked since the beginning of the atomic age. In the NATO-Warsaw Pact stand-off, parity in nuclear capabilities and symmetrical risks to each bloc leant to a tense balance. Everyone shared the burden of risking their homeland in the march up the escalation ladder. This is less true for the rough alignment of parties in the Indo-Pacific. There are neither strong alliance structures nor linkages between key nations (Japan, Taiwan, Australia, India) and the United States to elicit shared symmetrical risk or absolute confidence in the United States' willingness to act in allies' defense.
The unconnected bi-lateral nature of the U.S. security arrangements in the Pacific suggests that given the CCP's nuclear capability and ability to hold the United States and allied forces in the region at risk, allowing other nations to develop their own survivable nuclear strike capability could be a significant deterrent. A nuclear-armed Japan, for example, would present a dilemma for the CCP's decision to strike U.S. bases and facilities in Japan. This allied domestic nuclear capability prevents CCP leadership from boxing U.S. leadership into choosing nuclear exchange in order to defend its ally's homeland, changing the calculus fundamentally by dramatically increasing the speculative cost of striking Japan.
Paradigm Shift 6: There are two Chinas; the diplomatic recognition of Taiwan
Perhaps the most important change of perspective relates to how the United States (and resultantly the world community) sees and incorporates the Republic of China into the global community. It would cost the United States and other like-minded allies relatively little to recognize Taiwan formally; to bring it fully into the diplomatic and economic structures the United States and allies are intent on defending. Significantly, such steps would make the cost to the CCP of forcing reunification tremendous.
Doing away with the ambiguity surrounding the status of Taiwan and making it clear that CCP ambitions to settle any "internal" matters must reckon with a global response could serve as a significant deterrent step. The political, military, and economic linkages between Taiwan, the United States and others that will stem from formal recognition create further additive cost and corresponding risk to any CCP effort to subdue the Republic of China. There are a number of specific steps the United States could take in this vein, including replacing the Taiwan Relations Act with a bi-lateral treaty extending collective security protections; increasing military cooperation through foreign military sales; and committing to either an enduring presence of United States forces in Taiwan or at key times of the year.
“It is an unfortunate fact that we can secure peace only by preparing for war.” John F. Kennedy – Speech at Civic Auditorium, Seattle, Washington. September 06, 1960.
The world has changed dramatically since 1960, but the role of the United States has not. Lulled by the long period without such villains, the rise of the PRC serves to remind what is required of the United States and her people to secure the peace the world desires.
The United States and the world would not seek conflict out, but like the Soviets before them, President Xi and the CCP seem intent on offering a choice between their brand of neo-totalitarianism or a fight. Peace is achieved through strength; to have it on favorable terms, the United States must prepare for war.
Mustering the wherewithal to meet this challenge demands a change of perspective. Shifting paradigms as described above will ensure that the United States sees and acts clearly to preserve the system that birthed unprecedented freedom and security across the globe. They enable the United States to posture, prepare and produce the combination of societal strengths and international alliances that make for effective deterrence and, barring that, win wars.
LtCol Matthew R. Crouch, United States Marine Corps, is a Non-Resident Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security. A graduate of the United States Naval Academy, he holds master’s degrees in Political Science and International Business Administration and is an Olmsted Scholar.
The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any agency of the U.S. government or other organization.

The Pressure Is the Message: What Xi and Putin Faced in Shenzhen
By Emzari Gelashvili • RealClearDefense
China’s Revised Mobilization Law and the Expanding Reach of National Defense
By Muhammad Shoaib • RealClearDefense
U.S. Putting Weapons in Space: A Strategic Blunder?
By Ajey Lele • RealClearDefense
The Clearance Myth Is a Readiness Problem
By Elijah Fernandez • RealClearDefense
The Pentagon's Next Readiness Test Should Begin When the Cloud Goes Dark
By Colton Overcash • RealClearDefense

U.S. Putting Weapons in Space: A Strategic Blunder?
By Ajey Lele • RealClearDefense
U.S. Senate Seeks to Exchange Shipbuilding Funds for More Munitions
By Naval News
F-35C Completes First Launch and Recovery Trials on a Ford-Class Carrier
By Navy T.
USS George Washington Leaves Mideast As Trump Mulls Ending Iran War
By S&S
ULA’s Latest Launch Failure Spells Trouble for Space Force
By Greg Hadley, A&SF
