
DoD's Consulting Bloat Suffers from Rot
Published May 14, 2024 • Read time: 5m
In a recent opinion piece former Deputy National Security Advisor Nadia Schadlow lamented the return of “study season,” a time when the Department of Defense (DoD) and other agencies, commit millions in taxpayer dollars to produce reports that recycle old recommendations to support their latest budget. Her argument comes after Secretary Frank Kendall ordered a massive study that could determine the shape and structure of the Air Force for the next several decades. And like so many other of these costly and often fruitless efforts, DoD commissioned McKinsey & Company.
Consultancies like McKinsey are more than happy to indulge the Pentagon’s penchant for studying problems ad infinitum. After all, their allegiance lies in profitability, not national security. Their consultants are happy to spend a hundred hours a week buried in spreadsheets and PowerPoint to rationalize their exorbitant fees. That may be a fine fit for Citibank and General Motors, but it’s a bad model for a dynamic fighting force responsible for the defense of the nation.
There are plenty of keen minds among those in uniform and in the civil service to develop thoughtful plans for the military’s future. Large structures within each service make this a daily obsession. Having served in such organizations in the Army and the Joint Force, I can attest to their competence and commitment. Outsourcing this work to a consultancy is an insult to their valuable contributions, especially given McKinsey’s checkered history.
That history includes the consulting giant’s central role in the opioid epidemic that ravaged communities across the United States, particularly veterans. McKinsey poured fuel on the opioid conflagration by advising pharmaceutical companies like Purdue on how to market their addictive products, while at the same time consulting with the FDA and the VA, a clear conflict of interest for which they were forced to settle lawsuits with state AGs for $642 million.
More recently McKinsey has come under fire for its work for foreign enterprises, including state owned businesses in countries adversarial to the United States, including China and Russia. One of those firms is Rostec, a Russian state-owned firm that produces propulsion systems for many of the rockets that Russia has rained down on Ukraine since 2021. McKinsey advised Rostec even as it was “carrying out sensitive national security contracts for the Defense Department.”
Buy Smarter, Fly More
The Defense Department's Reorganization Problem Comes to Fightertown
America Needs To Spend More on Defense and Build More With It
The Factory Floor and the Balance Sheet
But McKinsey’s exposure in China, where its client list includes “China Construction Bank, China Resources Holdings Company Limited, and other firms with close ties to the CCP,” is even more extensive. McKinsey’s willingness to advise companies, including some involved in Beijing’s military buildup in the South China Sea has raised concerns among lawmakers about misuse of classified information, despite McKinsey’s assurances about firewalls.
Other parts of the federal government have taken notice and acted responsibly. In 2020 the General Services Administration (GSA) terminated a multiple award schedule contract with McKinsey because an IG investigation found the firm failed to cooperate with a pre-award audit and charged rates 10% higher than originally proposed. The discrepancy would have cost the government upwards of $65 million in overcharges.
In April 2022 the FDA announced it was halting contracts with McKinsey pending investigations into whether “the company failed to divulge potential conflicts of interest over its work for both the FDA and opioid manufacturers.”
The Pentagon was undeterred. After the racial unrest of 2020, the Navy implemented a service-wide task force on diversity, equity, and inclusion and hired McKinsey. The Navy’s Task Force One proceeded from the same assumption as most DEI programs in America – all institutions are systemically racist, and the only cure is making racial considerations part of every decision.
It is difficult to envision a more damaging proposition to an organization like the Navy, where fighting men and women must work together unquestioningly to support the mission and protect one another. But when bad policy needed justification, McKinsey was there.
The company released several studies on diversity in the workplace over the years, all of which made some form of the claim that a more diverse workforce equaled higher profits. Indeed, the work justified an entire business line for McKinsey, including leadership development courses that excluded white employees it ran for multiple corporations. One problem: the study, which informed a massive cultural change in the Navy, was significantly flawed. Several researchers, using the same data as McKinsey, in addition to identifying substantial methodological errors, could not replicate the firm’s findings.
That the Navy’s experience here, with senior leaders embarrassed in Congressional hearings and a string of brutal press, did not give the Air Force pause is eyebrow raising. While McKinsey proudly heralds its veteran hiring program, this is neither a defense for their past missteps nor an indicator they possess the in-depth military knowledge needed to steer the future of the Air Force. Most of their newly-minted MBA wunderkind lack practical backgrounds in military history or lessons learned, as well as the human condition in war.
Even their military hires, drawn largely from junior officer ranks, lack experience with strategic levels of war and the corporate military. This absence leads to bubbly thinking that can create a misalignment of incentives, one that prioritizes cost-cutting measures or even outsourcing strategies that compromise the integrity of the military services.
Handing a global management consultancy the keys to the Pentagon, as the Air Force seems primed to do, is a reckless proposition. The past two decades have taught us that America does not have a preordained right to victory in war. We certainly won’t achieve it by overpaying consultants to continually study problems, or worse, to give us flawed advice even as they counsel our adversaries.
Cale Brown is a Senior Advisor at Polaris National Security and a retired Army colonel.

Iron Raven: Remembering Colonel Joseph B. Conmy, Jr.
By Louis Marano • RealClearDefense
Stand Proud of the Force
By Jay Rogers • RealClearDefense
How a Dying Agency Turned Fentanyl Into a Weapon of Mass Destruction
By Barry Angeline • RealClearDefense
The Pressure Is the Message: What Xi and Putin Faced in Shenzhen
By Emzari Gelashvili • RealClearDefense
China’s Revised Mobilization Law and the Expanding Reach of National Defense
By Muhammad Shoaib • RealClearDefense

Marine Corps Hero Under Federal Investigation
By Laporta, Burnham & Watson, CBS
A Postmortem of Maneuver Warfare in the U.S. Marine Corps
By Donald Vandergriff
U.S. Putting Weapons in Space: A Strategic Blunder?
By Ajey Lele • RealClearDefense
U.S. Senate Seeks to Exchange Shipbuilding Funds for More Munitions
By Naval News
F-35C Completes First Launch and Recovery Trials on a Ford-Class Carrier
By Navy T.
