
JD Vance's Hillbilly Fallacies about Ukraine Aid
Published Feb. 5, 2024 • Read time: 4m
Recently, in a rebuke of renewed deliberations on Ukraine military aid, Sen. JD Vance sent a memo to GOP lawmakers claiming a lack of oversight by the Biden Administration Ukraine Armed Forces of aid allocation. Previously, Sen. JD Vance claimed Congress is looking to cut Social Security benefits for retirees in order to buy Ukrainian ministers “a bigger yacht”. The statement sparked a firm rebuke by fellow Republican Senator Thom Tillis, who described it as “total and unmitigated bull‑‑‑‑.”
The GOP finds itself starkly divided over Ukraine aid, which has torn a rift between presidential candidates and otherwise friendly Senate colleagues. Heading into the 2024 election, voters deserve to know how Ukraine aid works and what it has been spent on to objectively consider the candidates. Unsubstantiated claims like Vance’s get in the way, clouding public discourse on US foreign policy and our strategic positioning amid the Ukraine-Russia war.
Financial shortfalls in funding for the Social Security Administration should not be discounted. A report by the Congressional Research Service finds the program will be unable to adequately pay scheduled benefits by 2034. But benefits for retirees and support for Ukrainian defense against Russian invasion are not mutually exclusive. Backing our allies can not be short stopped over the looming financial challenges of social program spending.
In an earlier interview, Vance described US aid to Ukraine as “writing a blank check”. But that’s clearly inaccurate. As Hudson Institute senior fellow Luke Coffey explains, “Every dollar spent in support of Ukraine is authorized by Congress and used for a specific purpose.” Furthermore, the federal government carefully audits expenditures through the Ukraine Oversight Interagency Working Group and with the support of hundreds of personnel across 20 US oversight organizations.
Data from the Kiel Institute for the World Economy, a German think tank, breaks down the total of $75.4 billion in US aid to Ukraine sent over the past two years. 61% has been used to support Ukrainian military operations, with 31% allocated to replenish Department of Defense weapons and equipment reserves. The remaining aid supported the Foreign Military Financing program, the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative, and the Economic Support Fund. Only 2% ($2.7 billion) was allocated to emergency food supply, health care and other humanitarian initiatives.
In short, aid to Ukraine comes primarily in the form of direct arms and ammunition from the US military. Remaining dollars spent help the development of Ukrainian defense technology and support military training and intelligence operations. Congressional expenditures helps restock the Department of Defense, update America’s arsenal, and obtain valuable intelligence on one of our greatest competitors, Russia. Ukraine aid proposals don’t “write a blank check” for foreign politicians, they help defend a US ally while stimulating our defense industry.
Conservative opposition to foreign or military aid isn’t a new phenomenon. Ron Paul’s anti-war positions defined an important lane in the 2012 Republican presidential primary. Since the Trump 2016 campaign proclaimed a policy of “America First”, a new generation of Republicans has advanced harsh criticism of aid to countries across the globe. A more isolationist sentiment grows among the ranks of Vance and his Republican congressional colleagues, including Sen. Josh Hawley, Sen. Mike Lee, and Sen. Tommy Tuberville.
The issues advanced by Vance, Trump and others should not be willfully dismissed. Unchecked foreign aid spending and endless military entanglements are serious issues for the United States. From Biden’s promise of $6 billion to Iran shortly before the October 7 Hamas attacks on Israel, to the haunting history of the Vietnam War, a large sector of Americans view any international presence with deep skepticism. Republicans and Democrats alike share detest “forever wars” and military intervention, recalling the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. But these concerns must be decoupled from the realities of military aid to Ukraine.
Foreign policy is a complicated policy topic involving diplomacy, defense, culture and history. Americans deserve good-faith discussions about our alliances, counterterrorism efforts, military strategy, and positioning against Russia, China, and Iran. But to do so, the public deserves to see all the facts. By misrepresenting the data, Sen. Vance does a disservice to our national security resolve and his constituents.
Sam Raus is a Young Voices Contributor studying public relations and political science at the University of Miami. His political commentary has appeared in the Standard-Examiner, South Jersey Times, and Haddonfield Sun. Follow him on Twitter: @SamRaus1

South Korea’s Nuclear-Powered Submarines After the Midterms
By Jihoon Yu • RealClearDefense
Why Build a Billion-Dollar Warship if a Cheap Drone Can Sink It?
By Ege Can Gün • RealClearDefense
Megaspeed Proves: Congress Must Act on Chip Security
By Michael Groen • RealClearDefense
Creating a MEF Insurance Policy
By Steven Bancroft • RealClearDefense
Operation Epic Fury and the Illusion of Victory
By Stephen D. Cook • RealClearDefense

South Korea’s Nuclear-Powered Submarines After the Midterms
By Jihoon Yu • RealClearDefense
Why Build a Billion-Dollar Warship if a Cheap Drone Can Sink It?
By Ege Can Gün • RealClearDefense
Creating a MEF Insurance Policy
By Steven Bancroft • RealClearDefense
U.S. Navy Used Expired Munitions During Iran War
By Riley Ceder, Navy Times
The Coast Guard Icebreaker Nobody Wanted
By David Roza, Task & Purpose
